
Most owners open with a single question. What is my business worth? It feels like the right place to start. It isn't.
A number offered in a first meeting costs nothing to give, and it tells you almost nothing about how the next twelve months will go. The stronger opening is narrower and harder. What will you put in writing?
The questions to ask a business broker before you hire one should leave you clearer about your own company, not just about the advisor across the table. A well-run interview shows how a firm measures earnings, screens buyers, restricts access to your financials, structures a note, and coordinates with your CPA and attorney. It also separates three figures owners routinely blur: the estimated business value, the asking price you present to buyers, and the final sale price a buyer pays. If the first meeting doesn't produce that clarity, a second meeting rarely fixes it.
1. What Is Your Experience Selling Businesses Like Mine?
Ask it plainly, early, and listen for specifics instead of adjectives. The 2023 National Mainstreet Small Business Research Study examined 500 privately held U.S. businesses with annual revenue between $500,000 and $5 million, and owners in that study ranked a broker's proven track record and perceived knowledge of the business being sold among the most consistent selection requirements (IBBA small business owner research).
Then test the claim in writing. Ask for the number of completed transactions in your sector, the revenue ranges involved, the deal structures used, the average time to close, and whether the advisor personally led each cited deal or rode along inside a larger firm. A strong answer names patterns, not trophies.

For example: a Twin Cities managed services provider with 20 employees and a recurring-revenue contract base asks how many MSP sales the advisor closed in the past several years, and what share of those buyers were strategic acquirers versus financial buyers. The answer tells you whether you're speaking with a specialist or a generalist. The same test fits an owner-dependent manufacturer, a Minneapolis e-commerce brand, a home-services company, or a professional services firm: ask how the advisor proved customers, contracts and staff would stay after the founder stepped back.
- Ask for references from past sellers: confirm each one will take your call, and ask what the advisor handled well and what slipped.
- Request two or three comparable engagements without client names: sector, size, structure and outcome are usually enough to judge relevance.
- Confirm who works your file: the person in the meeting should be the person running the process.
2. How Do You Determine What My Business Is Worth, and Which Method Do You Use?
Three numbers get tangled in almost every first conversation. The estimated business value is the advisor's or appraiser's assessment, built from financial data and market evidence. The asking price is the figure you present to buyers, and it can sit above what the market will support. The final sale price is what a buyer agrees to pay after diligence and negotiation.
Then get to method. Seller's discretionary earnings, usually called SDE, adds the owner's compensation and certain personal or one-time expenses back to pre-tax profit, which suits smaller owner-operated companies. EBITDA, earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, is the more common measure in the lower middle market, where a buyer expects to hire a manager. Normalized earnings strip out items that won't continue after you leave.
The AICPA Statement on Standards for Valuation Services distinguishes engagements that produce a conclusion of value from those that produce a calculated value, and it covers business interests, intangible assets, financing, tax, financial reporting, mergers and acquisitions, and planning. Ask which of those you are buying, along with the standard of value, the valuation date, and every normalization adjustment.

Hypothetical example, assumed for illustration only: a company reports $900,000 in pre-tax profit, adds back $150,000 of owner compensation above a market salary, and adds back $50,000 of one-time legal costs, producing an SDE estimate of $1,100,000. The multiple applied to that figure is an assumption for this example, not a market rate.
Plain test: if the advisor can't show you the multiple, the comparable evidence behind it, and the adjustments that produced it, you're looking at an asking price, not a valuation.
3. How Will You Protect My Confidentiality During the Sale Process?
Discretion is a promise. Confidentiality is a process, and you should ask to see it described in stages. Guidance on avoiding confidentiality breaches in a business sale identifies exposure at every stage, marketing, negotiation and due diligence, and it emphasizes staged disclosure, careful selection of recipients, and binding nondisclosure agreements.
Ask specific questions. Will the listing use a blind profile with no company name, city or owner name? How are buyer identities and beneficial owners verified? What proof of funds is required before financial statements are released? Who can access the data room, and are documents watermarked and access-logged? What happens, step by step, if information leaks anyway?

Hypothetical example, for illustration only: a Minnesota home services company is marketed as a residential and light commercial provider within a stated revenue range, with no name, address or customer list, until a buyer is verified and has signed a nondisclosure agreement.
An NDA gives you a remedy after a leak. Staged disclosure and identity checks are what keep the leak from happening.
- Decide who knows inside the business: name the employees who will be told, and let the advisor work around that list.
- Have counsel review the agreement: scope and enforceability are legal questions, not marketing ones.
- Keep data room access named and revocable: a shared link isn't a control.
4. How Do You Find, Screen, and Qualify Buyers?
Buyer quality shapes your outcome more than marketing volume does, so ask how buyers are sourced and how they're tested. A credible answer names the categories: strategic acquirers inside your industry, private equity groups, search funds, individual buyers who intend to run the company, and your own managers or employees. Each brings different financing, different timelines, and different appetites for structure.
Then ask how financial capacity is confirmed before a meeting happens, how many buyers are contacted and how many typically reach detailed discussions, and how buyer interest will be reported to you. No advisor can promise a specific number of interested parties.

Hypothetical example, assumed for illustration only: an advisor identifies twelve potential buyers for a specialized Minnesota manufacturer, four sign nondisclosure agreements, two submit preliminary indications of interest, and one moves to letter-of-intent discussions. Those figures illustrate a funnel; they aren't a benchmark.
What proof of funds actually means
A lender's letter expressing interest is not proof of funds. Ask for evidence of liquid capacity, ideally a statement or a letter confirming an available facility, sized against the equity injection the deal requires. For an owner-dependent MSP or a professional practice, also ask how the advisor would handle a competitor buyer, or a current customer who asks to review the books.
5. What Fees Will I Pay, and When Are They Due?
A percentage quoted out loud is not a fee schedule. SEC guidance for M&A brokers states that a broker representing both a buyer and a seller must clearly disclose the parties represented and obtain written consent from both parties to joint representation, and it permits transaction-based compensation when the parties agree to it. That consent deserves more of your attention than the headline rate.
Ask whether compensation is a percentage of enterprise value, equity value, cash received at closing, assumed debt, earn-outs, seller financing or future payments. Confirm when fees become payable, whether a minimum applies, how expenses are reimbursed and whether they're capped, the contract term, your termination rights, exclusivity, and any post-termination tail covering buyers introduced during the engagement. If a separate valuation is quoted, read what a business valuation costs so both fees are measured on the same basis.

Read the tail clause twice. It decides whether you owe a fee on a buyer the advisor introduced who returns to the table after the engagement ends.
Fee questions to ask a business broker before you sign
Put the formula in writing, showing whether the percentage applies to enterprise value or to cash you receive at closing. A low headline rate with broad triggers and a long tail can cost more than a higher rate with a clean definition and a short obligation.
6. How Long Will the Sale Take, and What Could Cause Delays?
Ask for stages rather than a single date. A sale usually moves through preparation, valuation, marketing, buyer discussions, letter of intent, due diligence, financing and closing, and each stage carries its own dependencies. Ask how long each one takes for a business your size in your sector, and ask what has caused delays in the advisor's recent work.
Then listen for candor. Incomplete or inconsistent records, owner dependence, customer concentration, lease and contract consents, financing approvals and shifts in credit markets are the usual culprits. An advisor who names them before you ask is telling you something useful.
Hypothetical example, assumed for illustration only: an owner spends six months preparing statements before marketing begins, and diligence runs several weeks long because customer contracts require consent to assignment. Those durations illustrate cause and effect, not a typical timeline. For a fuller view of sequencing, read how long it takes to sell a business.
Build slack into your own plans
Don't renew a lease, commit to major equipment, or set a retirement date against a closing date you can't control. Ask for a realistic range, and ask what the advisor does when a process stalls for a month.
7. How Will You Prepare My Business and Financial Records for Buyers?
Preparation is where value gets protected. Due diligence guidance from SFA CPA on digging deeper into the financials emphasizes reconciling financial statements, tax returns, internal financials and IRS transcript data, documenting add-backs, proving cash, and evaluating revenue quality and customer concentration.
Expect to assemble three to five years of statements and returns, interim statements, general ledger detail, an adjusted earnings schedule, customer concentration data, pricing history and every asset that transfers. Ask for the written diligence checklist before marketing starts, plus the working definition of adjusted EBITDA and how working capital and debt-like items will be treated.
Hypothetical example, for illustration only: a professional services firm discovers that one client represents a large share of revenue, then spends several months broadening the base before the company is shown to buyers. The concentration figure here is an assumption.
For a list of what buyers routinely request, see documents needed to sell a business.
Owner dependence is a valuation issue
If your MSP's top accounts call you and not the service desk, or the plant floor runs on your relationships with two suppliers, that dependence gets priced. Ask which steps the advisor recommends to reduce it, and how long those steps take before marketing begins.
8. How Do You Handle Deal Structure, Financing, and Seller Financing?
Price is the headline. Structure decides what you collect. Start with the financing gap, because it is wider than many owners expect: the BizBuySell 2025 second quarter insight report found that 23% of surveyed owners planned to provide seller financing while 62% of buyers expected it to be part of the deal.
Define the pieces before you compare offers. A seller note is the portion of the price you lend back to the buyer and collect over time. An earnout is money paid later only if agreed results are met. Retained equity means you keep a minority stake after closing. Do not let the estimated business value or the asking price stand in for the final sale price; the offer that matters is the one with written terms behind it.
Ask for those terms in writing: cash at closing, note amount, interest, term, security, subordination, personal guarantee release, earnout formula, measurement dates, audit rights, escrow or holdback, and what happens on refinance, resale, missed payments, or default.
If the transaction is an asset sale, the IRS instructions for Form 8594 explain that buyer and seller generally must file when goodwill or going-concern value attaches to the transferred assets and the buyer's tax basis is determined by the purchase price. Ask how the price will be allocated across inventory, equipment, receivables, real estate, identifiable intangibles and goodwill, then confirm the split with your tax adviser.
Structure decides proceeds, not just price
Take an offer with cash at closing, a five-year seller note, and an earnout tied to revenue in the first two years. For an owner-dependent MSP in Minneapolis, the risk may sit in whether key clients renew under new ownership. For a St. Paul manufacturer, an e-commerce seller, a home services company or a professional practice, the same structure can price customer concentration, inventory quality, seasonality or referral flow very differently. Each component carries separate risk and separate tax timing, so compare net proceeds and security rather than the largest number on the term sheet.
9. Who Will Work on My Engagement, and How Will You Coordinate With My Other Advisers?
A sale touches your attorney, CPA, tax adviser, wealth planner, lender, and sometimes insurance and benefits specialists. Pin down the staffing before you sign. Ask who your primary contact will be, who handles day-to-day work, how responsibilities split between marketing, analysis, buyer communication and transaction coordination, and how often you will receive updates in writing. Ask whether the advisor works with your existing professionals or expects you to engage new ones, and get the answers into the engagement letter rather than accepting them over the phone.
Conflicts deserve the same directness. Does the firm represent buyers in other transactions, and how is that disclosed to you? Licensing and registration requirements vary by state, so confirm the applicable rules with the relevant agency rather than relying on a verbal assurance.
Name the person, then name the work. A firm's reputation doesn't answer who will be on the phone in week nine, when a buyer's lender asks for documents nobody prepared.
Exit Pathways' website associates its services with Mark Beaver, but its public page does not describe his role or who else works on engagements, so ask him directly which parts of an engagement he leads and which are handled by others.
Hypothetical example, for illustration only: a manufacturer keeps its own attorney and CPA, and the advisor agrees to weekly written updates with owner approval required before any information reaches a buyer.
10. What Should I Know Before Requesting a Confidential Valuation?
A confidential valuation is an estimate of business value built from your financial information, market evidence, and the purpose behind the request. It is not an asking price, and it is not a promise of what a buyer will pay.
Ask what information is required, how it will be protected, what the report will contain, and whether the result may be used for a shareholder agreement, estate planning or lender financing. Those purposes can call for different standards and different scopes, so ask which applies before work begins. Review the output with your CPA or attorney before relying on it for a legal, tax or financing decision.
Exit Pathways lists confidential business sales, business valuations, mergers and acquisitions advisory and exit planning among its services, and its public page currently displays a coming-soon notice rather than detailed engagement information. Confirm scope, deliverables and standards directly.
Hypothetical example, for illustration only: an owner requests a valuation to plan a transition over several years rather than to set an immediate asking price. The purpose and timeline are assumptions.
- Gather your statements first: three to five years of returns and financials shorten the process.
- Ask who may rely on the report: lenders and professional advisers often need to be named.
- Keep the purpose fixed: a valuation built for one use may not fit another.
How the Ten Questions Differ in Focus and Evidence Required
| Item | Core Concern | Request in Writing | Main Caution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Experience selling similar businesses | Relevant sector, deal-size, and owner-dependent business experience | Comparable engagement history, outcomes, references, and assigned team members | Confidentiality may limit verification; experience may not transfer across sectors |
| Valuation method and business worth | How value is estimated and how it differs from asking and sale prices | Valuation assumptions, earnings adjustments, multiples, and supporting data | A valuation is an estimate, not a guaranteed sale price |
| Confidentiality during the sale | Protecting sensitive information and limiting disclosure | Buyer screening, NDA process, access controls, staged disclosure, and breach response | Confidentiality risks cannot be eliminated entirely |
| Finding and qualifying buyers | Reaching suitable buyers and confirming their capacity and intent | Buyer qualification criteria, financing checks, and reporting process | Buyer interest does not guarantee a completed transaction |
| Fees and payment timing | Understanding compensation, expenses, and post-engagement obligations | All fees, expense limits, success-fee calculations, tail provisions, and termination terms | Broad tail provisions and additional costs may create obligations |
| Sale timeline and possible delays | Process stages, timing expectations, and sources of delay | Stage-by-stage timeline range and communication schedule | No closing date can be guaranteed; delays may extend the process |
| Preparing the business and financial records | Organizing records and addressing risks before buyer review | Preparation scope, normalized earnings adjustments, and information memorandum contents | Unsupported adjustments can harm credibility with buyers |
| Deal structure, financing, and seller financing | Comparing payment terms, financing sources, and post-sale risk | Structure scenarios, financing verification, and seller-note or earnout terms | Deferred payments carry risk and may have tax or legal consequences |
| Engagement team and coordination with advisers | Defining responsibilities, communication, and conflict management | Team roles, update schedule, adviser coordination, and conflict disclosures | Larger teams and outside coordination may add complexity, cost, or time |
| Requesting a confidential valuation | Clarifying the valuation's purpose, scope, and information protections | Required information, confidentiality safeguards, report contents, and applicable standards | A valuation is not a guaranteed sale price and may not suit every purpose |
Turning Broker Answers Into a Confident Decision
By the second meeting you should have paper, not impressions. Put the answers side by side in one document and score them on what moves money and risk: sector experience with companies your size, the valuation method and the evidence behind the multiple, how confidentiality is enforced at each stage, how buyers are qualified and financed, the full fee formula including triggers and tail, a realistic timeline with named delay risks, and who exactly will run the engagement alongside your attorney and CPA.
Two habits keep the comparison honest. First, write down which figure is which: the estimated business value, the asking price, and the final sale price are three different numbers, and a broker who blends them in conversation will blend them in an engagement letter. Second, ask every candidate the same questions in the same order and keep the written answers.
Vague answers are the loudest signal you will get. A broker who cannot describe a comparable engagement, cannot show how a multiple was built, cannot explain who sees your records and when, or cannot say who does the day-to-day work is previewing the next six months for you. The reverse is equally true. Specificity about process, offered freely and put in writing, is the closest thing to a preview of your own sale.
Choose the broker whose method you can follow, whose conflicts are disclosed, and whose fee you can calculate before you sign anything. That combination will serve you better than the highest price anyone quotes in a first meeting.
Exit Pathways offers confidential business sales, business valuations, mergers and acquisitions advisory, and exit planning. If you are weighing a sale in the next year or two, the most useful next step is a private conversation about where your company stands and what preparation could change the number. Visit Exit Pathways to request a confidential valuation or to speak with Mark Beaver about your business and your ownership transition timeline.